We buy houses all over Miami-Dade · En español
Home › Home values › Home values › Home values in Cutler Bay

What houses sell for in Cutler Bay: real sale prices

What single-family houses in Cutler Bay actually sold for over the last two years, from the county's public records.

Kindred Home Buyers · Updated November 2026 · Sales from November 2024 to October 2026
$635,000median sale price
$575,000–$710,000middle half of sales
$386median per square foot
363sales in 24 months
1,672 sq fttypical size
1965typical year built

The median price is 8% below the county-wide median ($690,000).

Comparing the first and second half of the period, price per square foot fell 3.9%.

By bedroom count

BedroomsMedian pricePer sq ftSales
3-bedroom$625,000$407224
4-bedroom$665,000$368116
5+ bedroom$744,500$34516

By year built

BuiltMedian pricePer sq ftSales
1960–1979$640,000$392161
1980–1999$791,000$35732
before 1960$588,000$392144
2000 and later$860,500$40026

By ZIP code

ZIPMedian pricePer sq ft
33157$690,500$425
33189$595,000$380

What if the house needs work?

These are sales of houses in every condition, though financed sales tend to be move-in ready. A typical 1,672 sq ft house at $386 a foot is worth about $645,000 fixed up. Here's what a common investor rule of thumb (70% of the fixed-up value, minus repairs) works out to as a cash offer:

ConditionRough repairsTypical cash offer
light work (paint, floors, cleanout)$41,800$410,000
medium work (kitchen, baths, some roof or electrical)$100,320$351,000
heavy work (roof, plumbing, electrical, structural)$183,920$268,000

Repair costs per square foot are rough illustrative assumptions, not a quote. Every buyer runs numbers differently: get several offers and compare them with the listing vs. cash calculator, or try the value estimator.

If you inherited a house in Cutler Bay, see how code liens and lien searches work there.

How we got these numbers: qualified (arm's-length) single-family sales in Miami-Dade County's public sales records, November 2024 to October 2026, with the most extreme outliers removed. We show totals and medians only, never addresses. This isn't an appraisal.

People also ask

How much is a house worth in Cutler Bay?
Over the last 24 months, single-family homes in Cutler Bay sold for a median of $635,000, about $386 per square foot, across 363 sales.
Get an offer on my house