
- House in decent shape, probate done, no rush: list it with a good local agent. You'll almost always net the most.
- Needs a lot of work but someone could still finance it, or you want competition: list it as-is with an agent and let several investors bid against each other.
- Can't be financed (bad roof, fire, structural, liens, title mess), family far away, or you need it handled: get written offers from two or three local cash buyers and compare them.
- Never let it go to a tax deed auction if you can avoid it. That's the worst outcome for the family.
The options side by side
| Option | Typical price | Speed | Takes any condition? | Costs to you | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fix it up and list with an agent | Highest | Months | No, you fix it first | Repairs, commission, closing costs, carrying costs | Families with time and money to renovate |
| List as-is with an agent | Good, set by competing bids | 1–3 months | Mostly | Commission, closing costs, carrying costs | Houses that need work but have no title or lien mess |
| iBuyer (Opendoor) | Near market, minus a fee | 3–8 weeks | No: excludes fire, major water/mold, structural | Service fee, repair credits | Newer, average-condition houses |
| Local cash buyer (like us) | Lower: priced for repairs and risk | 2–3 weeks, or when probate allows | Yes | Usually none | Heavy damage, liens, back taxes, title problems, families far away |
| Wholesaler | Lowest of the cash options | Varies, they need to find a buyer | Yes | Usually none, but less certainty | Rarely the best choice; know who you're dealing with |
| Online or estate auction | Uncertain | 1–2 months | Yes | Auction fees; buyers pay a premium, which lowers bids | Unusual properties, or when the family wants a public sale |
| Family member or neighbor buys it | Whatever you agree | Varies | Yes | Closing costs | When someone wants the house and can pay fair value |
| Keep it and rent it | No sale: monthly income | n/a | No, must be rentable | Repairs, insurance, management | Families who agree and can manage a rental |
| Do nothing | Worst | Years | n/a | Fines, taxes, and eventually the house | Nobody |
1. Fix it up and list it with an agent
If you can afford the repairs and the time, this usually puts the most money in the family's pocket. A renovated house gets financed buyers, and financed buyers pay the most.
The catch: you pay for repairs up front, plus commission (the national average for both agents was about 5.4% in 2025, and it's negotiable), seller closing costs, and taxes, insurance and utilities every month until it sells. Renovations on older Miami houses also tend to uncover more work: wiring, cast-iron plumbing, roof decking, unpermitted additions that need permits.
Pick this if: the house is basically sound, probate is done or nearly done, someone in the family can manage contractors, and nobody needs the money quickly.
2. List it as-is with an agent
This is the option most families don't know about, and it's often better than calling one "we buy houses" company. A good agent puts the house on the MLS as-is, often as cash or rehab-loan only, and lets investors and handy buyers compete. Competition pushes the price up.
The catch: you still pay commission and closing costs, there are showings, and cash buyers will still price in repairs. Title problems, open probate or big liens can make buyers walk away during the deal.
Pick this if: the house needs work but the title is clean, the liens are small, and you can wait a month or three.
3. An iBuyer like Opendoor
Opendoor advertises cash offers in Miami. It's quick and simple for the right house, but its own rules exclude fire damage, severe water damage, widespread mold, and major foundation or structural problems, and very old homes may not qualify. Expect a service fee, plus repair credits taken off after their inspection.
Pick this if: the house is newer and in average condition. Most inherited houses we see in Miami-Dade, built in the 1950s with deferred repairs, don't fit.
4. A local cash buyer (what we do)
A local buyer purchases the house as-is with their own money, pays off the liens and back taxes at closing, and handles the repairs after. We can sign a contract now and close when the court gives the personal representative authority, or once the heirs have a homestead order.
The honest trade-off: the price is lower than a renovated house sells for. A common investor rule of thumb is around 70% of the after-repair value minus the repair cost. In return you skip repairs, cleanout, showings, financing risk, commissions and the months of carrying costs.
Pick this if: the house can't be financed (bad roof, fire, structural damage, open unsafe-structure case), there are liens, back taxes or title problems, the family is out of state, or you simply want it done. Get at least two or three written offers and compare them with our listing vs. cash calculator.
5. Wholesalers
Many "we buy houses" ads are wholesalers. A wholesaler signs a contract to buy your house, then sells (assigns) that contract to a real buyer for a fee. They never intend to close in their own name. That isn't illegal in Florida, and we found no Florida law passed in 2025–2026 that specifically regulates it, but it means the price you get is the end buyer's price minus the wholesaler's cut, and the deal can fall apart if they don't find a buyer.
A version we see a lot with Miami-Dade estates: a company asks each heir separately to sign a quitclaim deed into a trust for a small payment, then sells the house at close to full value. Before you sign anything, read how to check a cash buyer.
6. Auctions
Online auction sites mostly carry bank-owned and foreclosure homes. Buyers pay a premium on top of their bid (Xome's is typically 5% or $2,500, whichever is greater), so they bid less, and there's no reliable public data showing auctions beat other options for families. A local estate auctioneer can make sense for an unusual property, or when an estate wants a public, arm's-length sale.
7. A family member or neighbor buys it
If a sibling wants the house, they can buy the others out at fair value, using an appraisal or a written cash offer as the benchmark. Neighbors sometimes want the lot. It's often the cleanest outcome emotionally. Do it through a title company so the money and the deed change hands properly.
8. Keep it and rent it
Miami rents are high, so this can work, but the house has to be safe and insurable first. Florida insurers can't refuse a roof under 15 years old just for its age, but older roofs need an inspection showing five or more years of life left. Vacant houses lose some standard coverage after 60 days. Every heir who owns a share has a say, and the income is split.
9. Do nothing
This is the most common choice and the most expensive. Taxes go unpaid and a tax certificate is sold. Two years later its holder can apply for a tax deed and the house goes to auction (see our tax deed countdown). Code fines keep running every day on an empty house (see the code lien calculator). Families who wait often end up with far less, or nothing.
How to decide in five minutes
- Could a normal buyer get a mortgage on it today? If the roof, electrical or structure is bad, probably not. That rules out financed buyers until it's fixed.
- Who can sign? If probate hasn't started, or there's no homestead order, any sale has to wait for that. A buyer who will sign now and close later saves time.
- What's owed? Check the property taxes and order a lien search. Big liens shrink the buyer pool.
- Can the family fund repairs and six months of costs? If yes, fix and list, or list as-is. If no, compare cash offers.
- Get numbers in writing from at least two directions (an agent's estimate and two cash offers) and compare the net, not the headline price.
People also ask
What is the fastest way to sell an inherited house in Florida?
Do I get less money selling to a cash buyer?
Is it better to sell an inherited house as-is?
Should I get more than one cash offer?
We buy houses, we're not lawyers. This is what we've learned doing this in Miami-Dade. Laws and fees change and every family's situation is different, so check with a Florida probate attorney, the Clerk or the Tax Collector before you act on it.